Is an HDTV Warranty Worth it?

I love technology, most of the time.  The joy of working and using powerful machines to do nearly anything you want them to is a source of excitement, income, and challenge that I have in my life every day.  One of the technologies that I really have enjoyed is my HDTV.  About 3 weeks ago I was watching a TV show on Netflix on my LG 50PS80 Plasma TV, when all of a sudden, there was a loud pop, and the TV set turned off.  Concerned, I turned the set back on and now all of the white areas of any show our TV source show up as off white with visible red dots and blue dots in the white area.  After calling into LG tech support, I learn there’s no warranty on the set because it was purchased over a year ago, but I did get the listing of several TV repair services in my area.  I promptly called each one up and got quotes as high as $350 to bring the TV in for diagnostics and repair.

Consumer Reports did a study in their December 2010 issue where they published a list of 198,049 LCD TV owners, where they purchased their TV’s  between 2007 and 2010.   The average LCD failure rate among all manufacturers came out to be 4.5% The Lowest surveyed brand based on failure rate was Panasonic at 2%, and the highest failure rate award goes to Mitsubishi at 12%.  Here’s a breakdown of the percentage of TV’s that have failed by manufacturer, by owners who purchased sets between 2007 and 2010.


Panasonic       2%
Sanyo                2%
Sylvania           2%
Sony                  3%
JVC                     3%
Visio                   3%
Sharp                 3%
Emerson           3%
LG                       3%
Insignia            4%
Toshiba           4%
Magnavox      4%
Philips             4%
Viewsonic      4%
Samsung         4%
Westinghous        8%
Polaroid             10 %
Mitsubishi          12%

The surveys also found that most TV owners suffered a break within the first year. 68% of those getting repaired were within the first year, and that 76% of those needing repair cost the owner nothing, again because of the usual one year warranty.

A similar survey was done at that time of 29,794 Plasma TV owners, and the average failure rate came out to be 4.3%. Panasonic failures came in the lowest at 3% Samsung was next at  4% and the LG failure rate came out to the the highest at 6%.


The great warranty debate

There are widespread debates on the purposes and credibility of extended warranties for expensive items such as cars, homes, rental units, boats, and HDTV’s.  I’ve always leaned towards investing in the extended warranty because it gave me the peace of mind to know that my investment will be covered.

In fact, when our videography business did a review of the Panasonic hmc40, the 3 year standard warranty was a key factor in our decision to buy multiple of these camcorders for our business.  If the warranty is not covered or included by default then many manufacturers or big box re-sellers such as best buy or sears will ask you to pay hundreds of dollars more to protect your investment.  For budget reasons, when I decided to buy my TV, I decided against investing in an extra warranty, and now I’m paying the price.

HDTV Self Service

If your a little bit of a geek, and you don’t mind digging into the organs of a desktop PC, then changes are, you can repair an hdtv as well.  Because I’ve been working in the field of IT for the last ten years, I decided to give it a try.   I researched likely points of failure on the TV, and learned of a communications board that could be the solution.

I ordered the board in question, a X-Comm board from, and for $28 + $20 shipping, the part arrived, and I took apart the TV and installed it myself.  I wish I could say this was a happy ending but unfortunately the part that purchased did not resolve the issue.  I contacted useful parts again and they said it could be a “Z comm board” on the unit, but it was hard to tell from the description and they didn’t have any boards in stock.

Learning the hard way

Moving forward with my purchases, I can definitely say that I’ve learned my lesson, and that when I make my next major investment, in a 4 core i7 macbook pro, I will be getting the full Apple care protection plan, as well as a hard plastic sleeve, and a laptop padded travel case no matter where I go.

If you ask me, is the Warranty worth it, I would definitely say Yes!

  1. I don't buy the extended warranty. It is too expensive. If you figured in all of the things you bought in the last ten years and what the warranty would have cost on each one. Then look at all of the items that never broke down within the extended period. You are still better off if you have to replace one of the items. However if you are talking about a very expensive item it might be different.

  2. HDTV is a huge investment for me so yes, a warranty would be really worth-it. For some other gadgets or appliances, it really depends on their value and lifespan.

  3. Please keep on posting such quality articles as this is a rare thing to find these days. I am always searching online for articles that can help me. Looking forward to another great blog. Good luck to the author! all the best!

  4. Hey Paul,

    I've had the same debates myself, and it's not an easy call sometimes. I generally will lean towards getting a warranty with more expensive items. Because I use mostly apple hardware, the laptop does qualify. Generally speaking items over $1000 I buy the extended warranty.


  5. I remember when I bought my sound system many, many years ago, and the store I purchased it from offered the extended warranty. The store knew that many people scoff at such warranty, so what they did was, if the customer purchased the warranty, but didn't use it, they would give the customer a credit for the value of the warranty.

    I had a digital camera fail on me almost three years after I purchased it. Luckily, I had purchased the extended warranty so I was able to get a replacement camera,

    As for computers, I won't get an extended warranty beyond the 1 year (2 years if purchased with my credit card). If something were to break, I can usually replace the parts myself for cheaper than the cost of the warranty.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts